GTA 6: Should You Trust Benedict Halifax?
Early in GTA 6's Vice City chapter, Jason and Lucia try to sell a stolen bronze statue and meet Benedict Halifax, a smooth antiques man who offers to handle the sale for a cut. The game lets you decide whether to hand the statue over. So should you trust him? This guide answers that and explains how the whole Dubious Provenance storyline plays out, with screenshots and videos from our own playthrough.
Short answer: It barely matters. Whether you give Halifax the statue or keep it, the story plays out almost the same way: he turns out to be a con man, you track him down through an antique store and a motel, and you finally catch him after a long chase. GameSpot recommends trusting him, because the build-up to the chase is funnier when Jason and Lucia feel properly burned. The choice that does differ comes at the very end, when you decide whether to shoot him.
Spoiler warning: this guide describes the Dubious Provenance storyline in Chapter 3.
Last checked 21 November 2026. Screenshots and videos are from our own PS5 playthrough of Dubious Provenance (all three parts). How the trust choice works is from GameSpot's guide.
Who Is Benedict Halifax?
After the events of Chapters 1 and 2, Jason and Lucia arrive in Vice City holding a bronze statue that several people want. They take it to Evelyn Andrews Antiques in Capri to sell. The owner, Evelyn, won't touch something that might be fake or stolen, but a well-dressed Englishman meets you outside: Benedict Halifax. He says he can find out what the statue is and sell it for a big profit.

The Statue Choice: Give It or Keep It?
When Halifax asks for the statue, a prompt lets you hand it over or keep it. GameSpot's verdict:
- Nothing bad happens if you trust him at this point. The statue isn't lost for good, and you'll be dealing with Halifax again either way.
- The outcome is the same. Halifax can't sell the statue whatever you choose.
- Trusting him is more fun. The later scenes, including one of the funniest chases in the story, land harder if he's got one over on you.
So if you're worried about losing the statue: don't be. Pick whichever fits how you're playing Jason and Lucia.
Part 2: The Antique Store and the Motel
When Halifax goes quiet, Jason and Lucia break into Evelyn Andrews Antiques after closing to look for clues. Jason climbs round the back, lets Lucia in, and they search the office. Halifax's things point to a cheap motel, so you head to the Sweetbay Inn and knock on doors until you find his room.


Walkthrough: Dubious Provenance (Part 2).
Part 3: The Chase
Evelyn reveals the truth: Halifax is a con man who has ruined her. GameSpot adds that even his English accent is fake. She sends you to a woman he's been staying with, and Halifax bolts the moment you arrive. What follows is a long chase:
- On the water: grab the Seashark jet ski and follow him across the bay, then dive in after him when he jumps.
- On foot and by bike: he keeps running through gardens and over fences; grab a bike and stay right behind him.
- Lucia takes over through the shops and cafés until you corner him on the pier.


Once he's caught, you clear out his storage unit, including jewellery you can sell and a purple '32 Hustler hot rod.

Walkthrough: Dubious Provenance (Part 3). Selling the Hustler: how to sell cars in GTA 6.
The Ending: Shoot Him or Not?
At the end of the questline, GameSpot says the game asks you whether to shoot Halifax. That's the choice with real weight, and the only one that changes what happens to him. GameSpot also notes that harming people feeds into Jason and Lucia's Criminal Profiles. We'll add exactly what each option does once we've tested both.
FAQ
Should you give Halifax the statue in GTA 6?
Yes, if you want the funniest version of the story. You don't lose anything: the statue's outcome is the same whether you trust him or not.
Is Benedict Halifax a scammer?
Yes. He's a con man who talks people into letting him "sell" their valuables, then keeps them. Even his English accent is fake.
Does the Halifax choice change the ending?
Handing over the statue doesn't. The decision at the end of the questline, whether to shoot him, is the one that matters.
How many parts is Dubious Provenance?
It's one official mission that plays out over several sessions. We've split our walkthrough into three parts: Part 1, Part 2 and Part 3.